An advisor whose name impresses in a pitch deck but who has not hired a sales team in a decade is a poor match for a founder who needs to build her first sales motion. The credential is real. The relevance is not.
The question to ask is not “has this person been successful?” but “has this person done exactly what I need to do next, recently enough that the market conditions are still comparable?”
Constraint-first matching produces advisors who are useful immediately. Logo-first matching produces advisors who are useful for signalling.